Evaluating the 30 Most Outstanding Men’s Club Managers in Europe
The Best Men’s Football Managers in Europe: A Comprehensive Ranking
In today’s world of elite football management, the landscape is constantly shifting. With legendary figures stepping back and rising stars taking their place, identifying the best managers in Europe can be quite the task. This guide ranks the top 30 men’s football managers on the continent, detailing a mix of seasoned veterans and promising newcomers.
The Selection Process
The journey to compile this list began with an extensive evaluation of approximately 50 managers. After narrowing it down to the final 30, input from various industry professionals—including coaches, sporting directors,CEOs, and chief scouts—was integrated to create a well-rounded assessment. Each manager is rated based on six key attributes that clubs commonly use in their hiring processes:
-
Coaching Acumen: This encompasses the ability to implement effective coaching principles, physical preparation strategies, and in-game decision-making.
-
Style: The attractiveness of a manager’s footballing philosophy matters. An entertaining and proactive style earns a higher score compared to a reactive, counter-attacking approach.
-
People Management: The ability to motivate players and elicit peak performance from a squad is crucial. A manager’s rapport and connection with players are significant factors here.
-
Communication: Clear communication and the ability to build trust both internally and externally are essential. This includes dealing with media and fans.
-
History/Achievements: Success and results matter—while trophies are the primary measure, other accomplishments like promotions and impressive performances with limited resources are also considered.
- X Factor: This encompasses creativity, innovation, and the ability to bounce back from setbacks. A manager’s potential for future opportunities also plays a role.
The Top 30 Managers
30. Dino Toppmöller (Eintracht Frankfurt)
Coaching acumen: 10/20
Style: 12/20
People management: 12/20
Communication: 11/20
History/Achievements: 2/10
X Factor: 4/10
TOTAL: 51/100
Toppmöller’s unconventional rise to the Eintracht Frankfurt dugout has been marked by tactical flexibility and a focus on fluid transitions. After achieving historic success in Luxembourg and serving as an assistant under Julian Nagelsmann, he has proven himself as a competent head coach.
29. Nuno Espírito Santo (Nottingham Forest)
Coaching acumen: 11/20
Style: 10/20
People management: 14/20
Communication: 12/20
History/Achievements: 2/10
X Factor: 3/10
TOTAL: 52/100
Having revived Nottingham Forest’s fortunes, Nuno has crafted a tactical setup focused on organization and efficient transitions. His approach has earned him a place among the best, illustrating the importance of structure and discipline in modern football.
28. David Moyes (Everton)
Coaching acumen: 12/20
Style: 9/20
People management: 14/20
Communication: 13/20
History/Achievements: 3/10
X Factor: 2/10
TOTAL: 53/100
Moyes’ return to Everton flashed signs of hope for a club in turmoil. His knack for rebuilding and organizational clarity has showcased his enduring value in top-level management, even if his tactical innovations have waned over the years.
27. Daniel Farke (Leeds United)
Coaching acumen: 11/20
Style: 12/20
People management: 14/20
Communication: 10/20
History/Achievements: 3/10
X Factor: 5/10
TOTAL: 55/100
With a solid managerial background, Farke’s patient development of players while maintaining tactical flexibility has been noteworthy. His experience in the Championship makes him a recognizable name in management circles.
26. Marco Silva (Fulham)
Coaching acumen: 12/20
Style: 12/20
People management: 14/20
Communication: 11/20
History/Achievements: 2/10
X Factor: 5/10
TOTAL: 56/100
Silva’s impact at Fulham has been impressive. His tactical expertise and ability to manage a roster have led the club to consistent mid-table finishes, solidifying his reputation across the league.
25. Rúben Amorim (Manchester United)
Coaching acumen: 10/20
Style: 12/20
People management: 14/20
Communication: 12/20
History/Achievements: 3/10
X Factor: 5/10
TOTAL: 56/100
After a challenging period at Manchester United, Amorim must reclaim his reputation; the potential remains, but consistency is vital for future success.
24. Brendan Rodgers (Celtic)
Coaching acumen: 12/20
Style: 12/20
People management: 13/20
Communication: 13/20
History/Achievements: 4/10
X Factor: 3/10
TOTAL: 57/100
Rodgers is celebrated for his tactical nuance and adaptability, maintaining a competitive edge in Scottish football. With an eye for player development, he has carved out a respected niche.
23. Ange Postecoglou (Unattached)
Coaching acumen: 9/20
Style: 11/20
People management: 14/20
Communication: 15/20
History/Achievements: 4/10
X Factor: 4/10
TOTAL: 57/100
Postecoglou’s tenure at Tottenham was characterized by chaotic brilliance. While he left an unpredictable legacy, fans appreciate his attacking ethos and strong relationships with players.
22. Thiago Motta (Unattached)
Coaching acumen: 11/20
Style: 12/20
People management: 14/20
Communication: 14/20
History/Achievements: 2/10
X Factor: 5/10
TOTAL: 58/100
After a tumultuous spell at Juventus, Motta showed promise with Bologna. His innovative tactics remain a talking point in management circles, and he is expected to return to prominence soon.
21. Massimiliano Allegri (AC Milan)
Coaching acumen: 14/20
Style: 11/20
People management: 13/20
Communication: 11/20
History/Achievements: 6/10
X Factor: 4/10
TOTAL: 59/100
Allegri’s experience is invaluable, but his conservative style has faced scrutiny, especially in a rapidly evolving tactical landscape. The upcoming season is critical as he aims to evolve his approach.
20. Vincent Kompany (Bayern Munich)
Coaching acumen: 11/20
Style: 13/20
People management: 14/20
Communication: 13/20
History/Achievements: 3/10
X Factor: 6/10
TOTAL: 60/100
As Kompany embarks on his journey with Bayern, his early success at Burnley suggests he has the potential to adapt to elite management challenges while maintaining clarity in his tactical philosophy.
19. Roberto De Zerbi (Marseille)
Coaching acumen: 14/20
Style: 14/20
People management: 12/20
Communication: 10/20
History/Achievements: 3/10
X Factor: 7/10
TOTAL: 60/100
Known for his high-risk style, De Zerbi’s time at Brighton and subsequent move to Marseille have demonstrated both his resilience and innovation, solidifying his standing in managerial circles.
18. Thomas Frank (Tottenham Hotspur)
Coaching acumen: 14/20
Style: 14/20
People management: 15/20
Communication: 13/20
History/Achievements: 2/10
X Factor: 6/10
TOTAL: 61/100
Frank’s promotion from Brentford to Tottenham highlights his tactical ingenuity and adaptability, making him one to watch moving forward in a competitive league.
17. Unai Emery (Aston Villa)
Coaching acumen: 15/20
Style: 14/20
People management: 14/20
Communication: 14/20
History/Achievements: 3/10
X Factor: 6/10
TOTAL: 61/100
Emery’s experience in European competitions is invaluable. His tactical flexibility paired with a keen understanding of player dynamics makes him one of the most respected names in the game.
16. Ernesto Valverde (Athletic Club)
Coaching acumen: 15/20
Style: 14/20
People management: 17/20
Communication: 13/20
History/Achievements: 6/10
X Factor: 4/10
TOTAL: 69/100
Valverde’s tactical sophistication has re-established Athletic Club as a contender, showcasing his management skills and tactical adaptability.
15. Gian Piero Gasperini (AS Roma)
Coaching acumen: 17/20
Style: 14/20
People management: 15/20
Communication: 14/20
History/Achievements: 6/10
X Factor: 5/10
TOTAL: 71/100
With transformative success at Atalanta, Gasperini’s appointment at Roma is a significant step in his storied career and holds promise for revitalizing the club.
14. Simone Inzaghi (Al Hilal)
Coaching acumen: 16/20
Style: 14/20
People management: 15/20
Communication: 14/20
History/Achievements: 6/10
X Factor: 7/10
TOTAL: 72/100
Inzaghi’s tactical discipline and proven record in high-pressure environments establish him as a respected figure, eager to take on new challenges in Saudi Arabia.
13. Antonio Conte (Napoli)
Coaching acumen: 16/20
Style: 14/20
People management: 15/20
Communication: 14/20
History/Achievements: 7/10
X Factor: 7/10
TOTAL: 73/100
After a successful season, Conte’s return to the top of Italian football demonstrates his tactical versatility and motivational prowess.
12. Mikel Arteta (Arsenal)
Coaching acumen: 16/20
Style: 16/20
People management: 17/20
Communication: 15/20
History/Achievements: 4/10
X Factor: 7/10
TOTAL: 75/100
Arteta’s innovative approach and adaptation of Guardiola’s tactics have seen Arsenal flourish. However, the question remains whether he can deliver silverware consistently.
11. Hansi Flick (Barcelona)
Coaching acumen: 16/20
Style: 16/20
People management: 16/20
Communication: 15/20
History/Achievements: 7/10
X Factor: 6/10
TOTAL: 76/100
Flick’s successful transition to Barcelona showcases his tactical intelligence and ability to harmonize his principles with the club’s traditional style.
10. Xabi Alonso (Real Madrid)
Coaching acumen: 15/20
Style: 16/20
People management: 17/20
Communication: 16/20
History/Achievements: 6/10
X Factor: 7/10
TOTAL: 77/100
Alonso’s rapid ascent underscores his tactical acumen and adaptability, positioning him as a future staple in elite football management.
9. Pep Guardiola (Manchester City)
Coaching acumen: 18/20
Style: 16/20
People management: 17/20
Communication: 17/20
History/Achievements: 9/10
X Factor: 7/10
TOTAL: 84/100
Despite facing challenges, Guardiola’s evolution in tactics and history of success keeps him at the forefront of football management.
8. Arne Slot (Liverpool)
Coaching acumen: 17/20
Style: 18/20
People management: 18/20
Communication: 19/20
History/Achievements: 6/10
X Factor: 7/10
TOTAL: 85/100
Slot’s impressive transition to Liverpool has established him as a managerial force, blending pressing principles with a structured attacking strategy.
7. Luis Enrique (Paris Saint-Germain)
Coaching acumen: 17/20
Style: 18/20
People management: 18/20
Communication: 18/20
History/Achievements: 7/10
X Factor: 8/10
TOTAL: 86/100
With a historic treble under his belt, Enrique’s philosophy at PSG shows a perfect blend of tactical flow and inspirational leadership.
Each manager in this ranking embodies a unique blend of styles, adaptability, and the potential for growth. The competition within European football ensures that any one of these men can make headlines, and the dynamics will continue to shift as they each face the challenges ahead.
